A Comprehensive and Unbiased Source of Information on United States Politics

Net Neutrality

Net neutrality refers to a principle that is applied to residential broadband networks, and potentially to all networks. Precise definitions vary, but a broadband network free of restrictions on the kinds of equipment that may be attached and the modes of communication allowed, and where communication was not unreasonably degraded by other communication streams would be considered neutral by most advocates. The principle of net neutrality and regulations designed to support the neutrality of the Internet have been subject to vociferous debate in various forums. Since the early 2000s, advocates of net neutrality rules have warned of the danger that broadband providers will use their power over the "last mile" to block applications they do not favour, and also to discriminate between content providers (e.g. websites, services, protocols), particularly competitors. Neutrality proponents also claim that telecom companies seek to impose the tiered service model more for the purpose of profiting from their control of the pipeline rather than for any demand for their content or services. Others have stated that they believe "net neutrality" to be primarily important as a preservation of current freedoms. As co-inventor of the Internet Protocol Vint Cerf has stated, "The Internet was designed with no gatekeepers over new content or services. A lightweight but enforceable neutrality rule is needed to ensure that the Internet continues to thrive." Critics, meanwhile, call net neutrality rules "a solution in search of a problem" and believe that net neutrality rules would reduce incentives to upgrade networks and launch next generation network services. Others argue that discrimination of some kinds, particularly to guarantee "Quality of Service," is not problematic, but highly desirable. Bob Kahn, the Internet Protocol's co-inventor, has argued that the term net neutrality is a regulatory slogan, which he opposes: "If the goal is to encourage people to build new capabilities, then the party that takes the lead in building that new capability, is probably only going to have it on their net to start with and it is probably not going to be on anybody else's net."

Joseph Biden on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: No position yet taken because there aren't any big problems yet
Description: Biden indicated he was reluctant to write what's known as "Network Neutrality" into law in the absence of actual problems. So far, there's scant evidence of consumers being blocked from going to legitimate Web sites at the speeds their Internet plans guarantee.
Citations:
1. Internet-freedom backers struggle on (8/13/07)
Sen. Joe Biden, the Democrat from Delaware, and Arlen Specter, the Republican from Pennsylvania, both indicated Wednesday that they were reluctant to write what's known as "Network neutrality" into law in the absence of actual problems. So far, there's scant evidence of consumers being blocked from going to legitimate Web sites at the speeds their Internet plans guarantee.
2. Senate ponders policing of Net neutrality offenses (7/13/07)
Others on the committee questioned the need for "preemptive" action against a problem they're not convinced exists. If the discrimination that Net neutrality advocates fear does occur, such a public outcry will develop that "the chairman will be required to hold this meeting in this largest room in the Capitol, and there will be lines wandering all the way down to the White House," said Delaware Democrat Joseph Biden.
Sam Brownback on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Opposes
Description: Has opposed the Internet Freedom Preservation Act, which would add net neutrality regulations to federal law.
Citations:
Hillary Clinton on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports Net Neutrality
Description: Senator Hillary Clinton supports net neutrality. She cosponsored a bill in the senate that would ensure net neutrality.
Citations:
1. Statement of Senator Clinton on Today's Reintroduction of Net Neutrality Legislation (7/26/07)
Senator Hillary Clinton supports net neutrality.
2. Net neutrality proposal revived in Senate (7/26/07)
Senator Hillary Clinton cosponsored the net neutrality bill in the senate.
Christopher Dodd on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports Net Neutrality
Description: Christopher Dodd co-sponsored the Internet Freedom Preservation Act which guaranteed net neutrality.
Citations:
1. Senator Dodd Co-Sponsors 'Net Neutrality' Act (7/23/07)
Chris Dodd signs on as a co-sponsor of the Internet Freedom Preservation Act. This act supports net neutrality.
John Edwards on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports
Description: Edwards doesn't want to squash grassroots media and support consolidation of the media which he feels would happen if we didn't support net neutrality.
Citations:
1. Edwards: Net Neutrality (8/13/07)
In a visit to Howard, Edwards says he supports net neutrality
2. John Edwards Writes to the FCC (10/15/07)
"Anyone winning rights to this valuable public resource should be required not to discriminate among data and services and to allow any device to be attached to their service." - Edwards
Rudolph Giuliani on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Uncommitted
Description: Giuliani has not yet taken a stance
Citations:
1. '08 Candidates Split Over Net Neutrality (7/10/07)
Article discussing net neutrality and various candidate positions.
Al Gore on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports Net Neutrality
Description: Al Gore has stated that "neutrality should be the central tenet that will set us on a path toward an open, democratic Internet where free speech and free markets are encouraged."
Citations:
1. Al Gore Promotes Net Neutrality (7/23/07)
"[N]eutrality should be the central tenet that will set us on a path toward an open, democratic Internet where free speech and free markets are encouraged" says Al Gore, in his new book The Assault on Reason.
Mike Gravel on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports
Description: Senator Gravel supports a free and open Internet with no restricted access to any site, for any reason. He has vowed to support legislation and regulation that promotes net neutrality.
Citations:
1. Net Neutrality (8/13/07)
Net Neutrality aims to keep the Internet free from large companies who are using their networks to limit the amount of websites their customers can view, and the speed at which they can view them. Examples range from, being forced to use the search engines your Internet Service Providers (ISP), only being able to view streaming videos that your ISP deems acceptable, and charging a website an extra fee to maintain the usual connection speed. Senator Gravel guarantees a free and open Internet with no restricted access to any site, for any reason. He will do this by supporting legislation and regulation that keeps you in control of your Internet usage.
Mike Huckabee on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports
Description: Being a governor, Huckabee hasn't voted on net neutrality legislation, but he supports the idea.
Citations:
1. Gov. Huckabee on Net Neutrality (8/13/07)
"The Internet is a highway and we don't restrict highways to 18-wheelers, if it's a car, an SUV, or a truck, you use the same highway."
Duncan Hunter on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Has not yet taken a public opinion
Description: Has not yet taken a public opinion
Citations:
1. 2008 Candidates Split Over 'Net Neutrality' (8/13/07)
Says Hunter hasn't taken a position yet.
Dennis Kucinich on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports
Description: Voted against the Internet Freedom and Broadband Deployment Act of 2002, which would have allowed big incumbents to offer broadband without any net neutrality provisions.
Citations:
1. Vote Result for Internet Freedom and Broadband Deployment Act (8/13/07)
Kucinich voting in favor of net neutrality.
John McCain on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Opposes
Description: "I strongly support innovation, and I believe that the network operators should get a return on their infrastructure investments, which will encourage more development of broadband capacity in the U.S." - McCain
Citations:
1. McCain Statement on Net Neutraility and Interconnection (8/13/07)
Says he opposes net neutrality.
Barack Obama on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Pro Net-Neutrality
Description: Barack Obama supports net neutralities. During a 2006 podcast he stated: "We can't have a situation in which the corporate duopoly dictates the future of the Internet and that's why I'm supporting what is called net neutrality."
Citations:
1. Network Neutrality (7/6/07)
This is a transcript of a podcast Senator Obama released outlining his support for net neutrality.
Ron Paul on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports Net Neutrality but Opposes Government Enforcement
Description: Ron Paul wants the internet to be free but does not believe the government should be the enforcer. This is why he did not support Bill HR 5252 Amendment 987 which would have legally protected network neutrality.
Citations:
1. Republican Debate Transcript, Simi Valley California, May 3, 2007 (8/6/07)
"But I trust the Internet a lot more, and I trust the freedom of expression. And that's why we should never interfere with the Internet. That's why I've never voted to regulate the Internet. Even when there's the temptation to put bad things on the Internet, regulation of bad and good on the Internet should be done differently."
2. G4 The Loop: One-On-One With Ron Paul (7/23/07)
At 5 minutes, 42 seconds Ron Paul discusses why he does not believe the government should regulate the internet.
3. Ron Paul interviewed on NORML (part 2 of 2) (7/23/07)
at 4 minutes and 55 seconds Ron Paul discusses why he believes the internet should be "totally free of government regulation."
Bill Richardson on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Supports Net Neutrality
Description: According to a statement on his website, Bill Richardson supports net neutrality. His official statement is: "The internet has revolutionized communication, education, and commerce. It has also become an essential part of exercising our right to free speech. And the very reason why the internet has become such an important part of our lives is because its network infrastructure transmits data at the same rate and with the same quality to every user. Government built the Internet, and, while it has been improved by the market, profits shouldn't be made by destroying the egalitarian nature of online information. I support net neutrality and as President I will fight to keep the internet free and open."
Citations:
1. Civil Liberties (7/23/07)
"Government built the Internet, and, while it has been improved by the market, profits shouldn't be made by destroying the egalitarian nature of online information. I support net neutrality and as President I will fight to keep the internet free and open."
Mitt Romney on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Has not publicly taken a position on net neutrality.
Description: Has not publicly taken a position on net neutrality.
Citations:
1. 08 Candidates Split Over 'Net Neutrality (7/19/07)
Talks about candidates stances on net neutrality
Tom Tancredo on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Opposes
Description: Tancredo has voted against net neutrality.
Citations:
1. Final Vote Results for Roll Call 239 (8/13/07)
Tancredo's vote - a nay
Tommy Thompson on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Opposes
Description: Opposes net neutrality
Citations:
1. '08 Candidates Split Over 'Net Neutrality' (8/13/07)
Says Thompson doesn't support net neutrality
Fred Thompson on Net Neutrality More on this candidate
Stance: Has not taken a public opinion
Description: At this time, Fred Thompson has not stated his views on net neutrality.
Citations:
1. '08 Candidates Split Over 'Net Neutrality''08 Candidates Split Over 'Net Neutrality' (8/13/07)
Gives his stance on net neutrality


loading...


close Close Window

Sign Up
Become a member!
This is all you fill out. Ever.

Username:

up to 16 letters/underscores/dashes
Password:

Confirm Password:

Party Affiliation


Login
Already registered? Login here.

Username:

Password:


close Close Window

Suggest an issue which should be tracked for this election

Title
Reasoning
Submit
headshot

close Close Window

Candidate's first name

Candidate's last name

Change candidate's affiliation

Candidate's official website

Additional Comments:


Please enter the first and last name of the candidate who you think should be added to this site. Entering the party your candidate is affiliated with, along with their official website will make the approval process faster. Additionally, if you have any comments please enter them in the text box.
Submit

close Close Window

Got an idea for the site? Please let us know.

To: moderators@IssueDictionary.com

Your email address (optional)

Type your message here: